1-Bedroom Apartments for Rent in Pelham Bay Under $2,500
As of September 2, 2026, Rentomatics tracks 23 1-bedroom apartments for rent in Pelham Bay under $2,500/month, starting at $1,800/month. Listings are aggregated from StreetEasy, Craigslist, Nooklyn, Zumper, and CityRealty and refreshed continuously.
Pelham Bay is a quiet, residential neighborhood in the northeast Bronx, wrapped around the western edge of Pelham Bay Park — at more than 2,700 acres, the largest park in New York City. It sits between the Hutchinson River and the Westchester County line, giving it a leafy, semi-suburban character that feels far removed from the density of the central and south Bronx. The housing is dominated by single- and two-family homes on tree-lined blocks, along with brick apartment buildings and co-ops clustered near the commercial strips. Westchester Avenue is the main artery, and Crosby Avenue anchors an old-school Italian-American commercial core of delis, bakeries, and family restaurants. The 6 train ends here at the Pelham Bay Park station, and City Island — the Bronx's fishing-village enclave — is a short ride away on the Bx29 bus.
One-bedrooms in Pelham Bay are the sweet spot for singles and couples who want a separate bedroom without taking on a roommate. Capping your search at $2,500/month keeps Pelham Bay realistic. That's a comfortable ceiling here — above the current average of about $2,043, so you'll have real choice.
23 listings available — updated September 2, 2026, refreshed continuously
Searching for a client?
Put the outreach on autopilot.
- We watch every major listing site for each client
- Landlords get contacted in your voice, within minutes
- Voucher-ready: CityFHEPS, Section 8, HASA fields built in
- Confirmed tours land on your calendar
Living in Pelham Bay
The vibe
The feel is calm, settled, and family-oriented, closer to a Westchester suburb than to most of New York City. There is a strong, long-rooted Italian-American presence, most visible along Crosby Avenue and Westchester Avenue, where longtime pizzerias, pork stores, and pastry shops set the tone. Pelham Bay Park is the neighborhood's backyard, with Orchard Beach (the so-called "Bronx Riviera"), the Pelham/Split Rock golf courses, hiking trails, and the historic Bartow-Pell Mansion Museum all inside its bounds. Evenings and Sundays are genuinely quiet, and the pace is unhurried compared to neighborhoods farther south.
Getting around
The 6 train is the spine, with its northern terminus at Pelham Bay Park station and additional stops nearby at Buhre Avenue and Middletown Road; the express <6> runs during rush hours to speed the trip toward Manhattan. Being at the end of the line means seats are usually available heading in, though the ride to Midtown or downtown is a long one. Bus service fills the gaps: the Bx29 crosses the bridge to City Island, and other routes connect toward Co-op City, Fordham, and the rest of the East Bronx. For drivers, the Bruckner Expressway, the Hutchinson River Parkway, and I-95 all meet nearby, making it one of the more car-friendly corners of the borough, with street parking far easier to find than in denser neighborhoods.
The rental market
The rental stock skews older and low-rise, built around houses rather than towers, so much of what is available comes as apartments in two- and three-family homes, prewar and postwar brick buildings, garden apartments, and co-op units. Renters will find more one-bedroom and family-sized layouts than studios, and modern amenities like doormen, gyms, and roof decks are uncommon — this is not a new-construction market. In-unit or in-building laundry, small yards, and driveway or street parking are more typical selling points. Rents run toward the affordable end of the New York spectrum, which is a large part of the neighborhood's appeal, reflecting the distance from Manhattan and the length of the commute.
Who it's for
Pelham Bay suits renters who want space, quiet, and green surroundings at a lower price than most of the city offers, along with easy car access and a genuine neighborhood community. It works especially well for families, park lovers, and anyone who values a suburban rhythm while keeping a one-seat subway ride into Manhattan. The honest tradeoffs: it is at the far end of the 6 line, so commutes to Midtown or downtown are long; nightlife, cultural venues, and trendy dining are sparse and mostly require a trip elsewhere; and the older, house-based housing stock means fewer luxury amenities and more variability in unit condition. Those who need a short commute or a lively night scene will likely feel the distance.
Frequently asked
How many 1-bedroom apartments are available in Pelham Bay right now?
As of September 2, 2026, Rentomatics tracks 23 1-bedroom apartments for rent in Pelham Bay under $2,500/month. Listings refresh continuously from StreetEasy, Craigslist, Nooklyn, Zumper, CityRealty, and more.
What is the rent for a 1-bedroom in Pelham Bay?
Among current Rentomatics listings, 1-bedroom apartments in Pelham Bay start at $1,800/month, with an average of $2,043 and a median of $2,000/month. Prices reflect 23 active listings updated September 2, 2026.
How often are Rentomatics listings updated?
Rentomatics continuously refreshes listings by scraping StreetEasy, Craigslist, Nooklyn, Zumper, CityRealty, Compass, Douglas Elliman, and OpenIgloo. Stale listings are removed within 5 days of last sighting.
Does Rentomatics show broker fees?
Yes. Every Rentomatics listing displays whether a broker fee applies, and users can filter to show only no-fee apartments. Broker fee status is inferred from listing source metadata when not explicitly provided.
What is Pelham Bay like?
Pelham Bay is a residential Bronx neighborhood near Pelham Bay Park, the city's largest park. It has a suburban feel, affordable rents, and the 6 train terminus. City Island is a short bus ride away.