Apartments for Rent in Carroll Gardens Under $3,500

Carroll Gardens has an Italian-American heritage with excellent food options. It's residential and peaceful, with beautiful gardens and brownstones. The F/G trains connect it to Manhattan.

35 listings available — updated every 3 hours

Carroll GardensBroker

StreetEasy

Verified

196 Sackett Street 4F

$3,450/mo

1 bed1 bath

View listing

Carroll GardensBroker

StreetEasy

Verified

535 Hicks Street 3

$3,399/mo

2 bed1 bath

View listing

Carroll GardensBroker

StreetEasy

Verified

671 Henry Street 3R

$2,800/mo

1 bed1 bath

View listing

Carroll GardensBroker

StreetEasy

Verified

230 President Street 2

$3,000/mo

1 bed1 bath

View listing

Carroll GardensBroker

StreetEasy

Verified

306 Bond Street 3D

$2,500/mo

Studio1 bath

View listing

Carroll GardensBroker

StreetEasy

Verified

188 West 9th Street 3F

$2,850/mo

Studio1 bath

View listing

Park slope/ South Slope/ Carroll Gardens/ Red HookLandlord

Craigslist

Park slope/ South Slope/ Carroll Gardens/ Red Hook, Brooklyn

$2,499/mo

Unverified source — exercise caution.

View listing

Park slope/ Carroll Gardens/Brooklyn Heights/Beorum hillLandlord

Craigslist

Park slope/ Carroll Gardens/Brooklyn Heights/Beorum hill, Brooklyn

$2,499/mo

1 bed

Unverified source — exercise caution.

View listing

Carroll Gardens - Brooklyn, NYLandlord

Craigslist

Carroll Gardens - Brooklyn, NY, Brooklyn

$3,500/mo

2 bed700 sqft

Unverified source — exercise caution.

View listing

Carroll GardensBroker

Douglas Elliman

Verified

14728 22nd Ave 1A, Queens, NY 11357, Carroll Gardens

$3,300/mo

3 bed5 bath

View listing

Carroll GardensBroker

Douglas Elliman

Verified

10521 53rd Ave, Queens, NY 11368, Carroll Gardens

$3,250/mo

3 bed2 bath

View listing

Carroll GardensBroker

Douglas Elliman

Verified

4616 Avenue M, Brooklyn, NY 11234, Carroll Gardens

$3,200/mo

3 bed1 bath

View listing

Carroll GardensBroker

Douglas Elliman

Verified

11110 14th Ave, Queens, NY 11356, Carroll Gardens

$3,200/mo

3 bed1 bath

View listing

Carroll GardensBroker

Douglas Elliman

Verified

33-05 143RD St 2FL, Queens, NY 11354, Carroll Gardens

$2,700/mo

3 bed1 bath

Below average price — verify the listing in person.

View listing

Carroll GardensBroker

Douglas Elliman

Verified

1233 Glenmore Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11208, Carroll Gardens

$2,500/mo

3 bed1 bath

Below average price — verify the listing in person.

View listing

Carroll GardensBroker

Douglas Elliman

Verified

1327 Bell Blvd 3, Queens, NY 11360, Carroll Gardens

$2,650/mo

3 bed2 bath

Below average price — verify the listing in person.

View listing

Carroll GardensBroker

Douglas Elliman

Verified

5748 256th St 2nd, Queens, NY 11362, Carroll Gardens

$3,500/mo

3 bed2 bath

View listing

Carroll GardensBroker

Douglas Elliman

Verified

13430 155th St, Queens, NY 11434, Carroll Gardens

$3,000/mo

3 bed1 bath

Below average price — verify the listing in person.

View listing

Carroll GardensBroker

Douglas Elliman

Verified

33-05 143RD St 1FL, Queens, NY 11354, Carroll Gardens

$3,000/mo

3 bed3 bath

Below average price — verify the listing in person.

View listing

Carroll GardensBroker

Douglas Elliman

Verified

4347 163rd St 2, Queens, NY 11358, Carroll Gardens

$3,000/mo

3 bed2 bath

Below average price — verify the listing in person.

View listing

Stop messaging landlords one by one

Sign up for free to see full details and we'll automatically reach out to landlords on your behalf. No payment info required.

100% freeNo credit card10+ listing sourcesAutomated outreach

Explore nearby

Apartments in Cobble Hill Apartments in Park Slope Apartments in Fort Greene 1-Bedrooms in Carroll Gardens Studios in Carroll Gardens Pet-Friendly in Carroll Gardens All Brooklyn Apartments